For a developing country like Bhutan, education is important
to accelerate developmental activities. While education has done much good to
the country and its people over the last 100 years, quality of education has
become the much debated issue for some time now.
There might be legitimate reasons for people to believe that
the quality of education has declined. But the good thing is that the issue is
being discussed in numerous forums small and big. There must be debates. Only
then will we be able to tell whether the quality of education has really gone
done or not.
But we must continually remind ourselves about the changing
times and the needs of our country. The education standards and the quality
that served Bhutan well in the past 50 years or so are no longer relevant
today. And the quality and standards of education we have set for our schools
today will not serve beyond a few years from now.
So, debates and discussions should actually be encouraged.
It would be worrisome indeed if people did not talk about things that affect
their lives, education above all.
And when we talk about quality of education, we cannot
markdown things like curricula in schools and colleges, recruitment and deployment
of teachers, teacher-student ratio, demographic change and all that. Overall,
we must have efficient monitoring systems that can remind us where the changes
or modifications are needed. Rigid systems often fail to function properly.
That we expect much from teachers is in fact good. Only by
expecting much from the teachers can we encourage our teachers to perform
better. But for that to happen, their welfare must be looked into. We can’t
just blame them without having given them what they require so that they are
inspired to work extra hard. We know that satisfaction level of teachers
is low, but what have we done about it? Teachers say they are paid low, but
have we considered revising their salary?
Of course, for a country like Bhutan, paying handsome salary
for every important profession is difficult. Our economy is small. But we could
certainly do something to raise their morale. Confidence and self-respect are
important things in any profession. Unhappy and demoralized professionals don’t
work for better results. We could only be flogging the dead horses or else. And
that could have chain reactions. In this case, it could come down to the
declining quality of education. Maybe these really are the causes already.
There are good reasons to believe they are, for why are so many of our teachers
not happy with their job?
If we are to have a good harvest at all, we must sow good
seeds. Just wishing for the quality of education to improve overnight won’t
help. We must get down to the roots of the cause, identify them and do what is
required of us to do to get them up and running.
Rather than trying to borrow foreign education systems, our
educationists and researchers should focus on the requirements of the country.
There is much to be discerned from our own education system. It is not how we
teach our children in schools and colleges that should matter, but what we
teach them. Values such as kindness, respect, obedience and sincerity must be
of course incorporated into the curricula, but those values should not weaken
the importance of other subjects.
Irrelevance, I think, is at the core of quality problem.
What our children learn in schools and colleges do not seem to prepare them for
jobs in the market. That’s why we have so many unemployed youths. Giving them
other options will not help, because there will be dissatisfaction.
If the quality of education must improve, just revising
school curricula is not the right way. Neither is bringing in foreign experts
who recommend foreign ideas that do not serve our needs. Relevant curricula,
highly-paid and motivated teachers, efficient monitoring systems and healthy
debates may be the answers. Do we have all these?
"Relevant curricula, highly-paid and motivated teachers, efficient monitoring systems and healthy debates may be the answers. Do we have all these?"
ReplyDeleteI agree.
Now How about we also have some "Sincere and Genuine" research and development program in our education system????/
Just my Thought....
Sangey,
ReplyDeleteI should say that you are very correct. Yes.... time to time Assessment and Monitoring stage should be developed.
Not only Debates at different levels, but the principle of Practice in the Bhutanese education system should be cultivated.
What you say on this????
Keep writing Dear
Well said Sangay, i envy you. I'm not at all happy the way our Education system is running, i know i cannot change it or solve the problem with my rudimentary ideas, but somewhere somehow i ain't happy with it. With all those old hackneyed educationists and ministers, i guess it will take lot of decades to change, but don't worry, our time will come when we stand and do thye work of some educationists, we'll change it... we'll do the work for the betterment of the people of our country...till then, let them do what ever they want to do!!! Keep writing, i'm alys there for your support. Vampire here.
ReplyDeleteWell said Sangay, i envy you. I'm not at all happy the way our Education system is running, i know i cannot change it or solve the problem with my rudimentary ideas, but somewhere somehow i ain't happy with it. With all those old hackneyed educationists and ministers, i guess it will take lot of decades to change, but don't worry, our time will come when we stand and do thye work of some educationists, we'll change it... we'll do the work for the betterment of the people of our country...till then, let them do what ever they want to do!!! Keep writing, i'm alys there for your support. Vampire here.
ReplyDeleteSangay, very insightful. It's however hard to figure out the short circuit. Is it the human resource at the center or at the base? Is it the wideness of the Syllabus or the narrowness? Is it the tightness of the policy or the looseness?
ReplyDeleteIf we begin- where do we begin?
But something is miscalculated and misconceived- quality of education has NOT deteriorated, it's felt so, because our Expectations have grown in relation with the outside world.
Good perspective. We need to keep adding new perspectives to this old discourse.
ReplyDeletei am still trying to figure it out...as an expatriate teacher located in thimphu, i suffer from the ivory tower point of view...no need to panic, i believe...
ReplyDeleteThank you all of you, for your valuable comments.
ReplyDeleteWe lack follow-ups. There are certain developmental activities designed by the education division to better the system and which has to be inculcated in every educational institutions big and small. The heads of the institution do carry out those responsibilities and that's it. There are no followups to what has been done. Which leads us to think that the particular programme is of less use or bluntly irrelevant.
ReplyDeleteThe other problem is less research on curriculum development. We have adopted curriculums from foreign lands which ironically has failed in their own country. I mean reading a poem on Abdul Jabber is not at all relevant to our ethnic stand nor is it current to the world news.
And what about EVS, the activities there are obsolete. It has to change. DDC has to change it or change the whole subject to science. Science is more fun, exciting and useful than EVS in Dzongkha with obsolete activities.
What say??